Key points:
- Taylor placed her gloves and belts in the centre of the ring after beating Flora Pili
- McGregor posted a series of messages urging her to postpone her retirement
- One asked her to have “one more for the Mac”; another paired his name with Taylor’s and Muhammad Ali’s
- Irish fans responded by telling him to leave her alone
- McGregor had campaigned for Taylor to fight at Croke Park as far back as 2023
Katie Taylor put her gloves in the middle of the ring at Croke Park on Saturday night, along with her belts. In boxing there is no more explicit gesture available. It means the career is over.
Conor McGregor spent the hours afterwards suggesting it might not be.
What he posted
The first message was warm enough. McGregor praised the scenes at Croke Park, said Taylor had looked better than ever – younger, fresher, renewed like the eagles – and finished with a religious flourish and four hashtags, among them #GoAgainKatie, #OneMoreTune and #RetirementPostponed.
Then it drifted. A second post asked Taylor to do one more for the Mac. Two minutes later, a third simply read: “McGregor Taylor Muhammad Ali.”
The response
Irish boxing supporters did not take it as intended.
One reply told him that fighters like him and Tyson Fury make a mockery of retirement that Taylor had done all she could, and that she should ignore the people telling her to have one more. It closed with a question that circulated widely afterwards: when was the last time Conor won a fight?
Another was blunter about what people thought was actually going on. The difference between them, it said, is that Taylor earned respect in Ireland and then conquered the world, and that nobody has ever seen her try to steal the limelight – which is exactly what he appeared to be doing.
That is the substance of the backlash. Not that McGregor said something cruel, but that he attached himself to somebody else’s farewell.
The awkward history
The reaction is complicated by the fact that McGregor has a genuine claim on Taylor’s Croke Park story.
When negotiations to stage her homecoming there stalled in 2023 over the cost of hiring the stadium, McGregor publicly pushed for it, offered to sponsor the event, and met Eddie Hearn to discuss whether it could be done. Taylor’s father Pete thanked him for the effort at the time. The fight ended up at the 3Arena instead, and Croke Park had to wait three more years.
He has backed her consistently for the best part of a decade, from Boston in 2018 through Madison Square Garden in 2022 and both Cameron fights. When she lost to Chantelle Cameron, he was at ringside telling her he loved her to bits.
So the man being told to stop is also the man who campaigned hardest for the venue she has just retired in.
Why it landed badly anyway
Because a retirement is not a negotiation, and because the request was framed around him.
“One more for the Mac” asks a 40-year-old woman who has just finished her career on her own terms, undisputed, in front of 80,000 people, to extend it for somebody else’s benefit. Pairing his own name with hers and Ali’s in the same breath did not help.
Taylor herself has said nothing in response, which is consistent with how she has handled almost everything in public for fifteen years.
She said in the ring on Saturday that she did not know of another country that would sell 80,000 tickets for a female athlete, and that she was convinced Ireland was the only place it could have happened. The people replying to McGregor this week appear to agree with her, and to have decided that protecting the ending is part of the job. Public opinion settles some arguments without a vote ever being called, unlike the contests behind political betting odds, which we cover in a separate guide.